I've been reading a lot of really interesting philosophical type books lately, both for class and my own personal enjoyment and I've learned a lot. (I'm also taking a political science class...so I've been thinking politically again...) From my post yesterday about Socrates being wise because he knew that he did not know, to what I've been reading this morning, John Stuart Mill's
On Liberty which was talking about toleration of others I've been thinking a lot about some interesting topics. I haven't really thought about what Mill was saying for sure (I read it about an hour ago), but it got me thinking nonetheless.
This debate about tolerance has been going on for CENTURIES, and for someone who was writing in the 1800s to talk about toleration blew my mind, especially how strongly he was pushing religious toleration. He said "Yet so natural to mankind is intolerance in whatever they really care about, that religious freedom has hardly anywhere been practically realized..." The United States like to pride itself on being tolerant and accepting of all types of people, and freedom of religion was a MAJOR component of the founding of the United States, but do we
really have religious freedom here? Yes, you're free to practice your own religion, or to not have one, but are you treated in the same way as others?
Christianity is so deeply ingrained in our culture that it's hard to be anything but. I get that we were founded on a strong christian base of various practices and denominations, but when the first amendment says "Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion." I think we need to take it seriously. Back in the 18th and 19th centuries, it would have been much less of a deal to set a national religion, but today there is SO much religious diversity within our country, trying to push Christianity in everything is a bit ridiculous. Don't get me wrong, I consider myself a Christian and I have absolutely nothing against Christianity as a religion, but I think we take it too far in our politics.
So many of the political arguments that divide our country center around religious problems, gay marriage, abortion, etc...and I think that we have to be able to remove religion from those problems and look at them as what they are without the Christian lens getting in the way.
Gay marriage- two people that want to get married of the same sex. How absolutely terrible is that? It's not. Don't get your panties in a twist because of someone else's decisions. You don't get to CHOOSE your own sexuality, so why should someone else CHOOSE whether or not you get married? I just don't get it. Come on now people. The bible says this or the bible says that; just because the BIBLE says it, doesn't mean that you HAVE to be against it. The bible also says that slavery is a natural condition...so do you believe in slavery because the Bible says it? Probably not. You have the capacity to decide for yourself whether or not you believe in gay marriage, but from a standpoint NOT involving religion, why would you have a problem with it?
Abortion- I'm not saying that I support abortion, but I don't see why someone else should decide what happens to someone else's body. There are SO many circumstances surrounding why a woman would get an abortion that I just don't feel like it is right for a law to say what you can and can't do to your body. That being said, I don't think that people should be able to have abortions past a certain point and I think there has to be a valid reason as to why someone does it, but I don't think that the limits should be so short that the woman doesn't have time to make a rational, well thought out decision. If you believe that life begins at conception, good for you. I feel like there are SO many complications that are natural that could end the life between conception and birth that it isn't as big of a deal as some people make it out to be. (I am not endorsing abortions in any way, shape or form, just giving my views here.)
If our CONSTITUTION/ Bill of Rights SAYS that we won't have a national religion, I really think we need to take religion and our politics and not put religious dogmas into our laws. We have to take a step back and look at the WHOLE picture and consider both sides of the argument. Mill talked at length about looking at both sides of an opinion before deciding which one you truly support and I really think that a lot of people need to be able to sit back and LISTEN to others' opinions before being so strong-headed themselves. Why can't we just support each other without tearing others apart because of their beliefs or opinions? I understand why people believe the opposite of me, I don't believe that they are always correct, but I support those opinions and would never HATE someone because of what they believe. My roommate and I are on the TOTAL opposite end of the spectrum on our opinions and some of our beliefs, but we embrace that. We support each other's opinions and we have GREAT discussions about this kind of stuff because we are able to see where the other comes from. Why can't everybody do that? I guess I'll never understand.
BTW- you can check out my roommate's blog at heathercarpe.blogspot.com :) It's REALLY good!